Computer Based Horse Race Handicapping and Wagering Systems: A Report William Benter Additional contact information William Benter: HK Betting Syndicate, Hong Kong Chapter 19 in, 2008, pp 183-198 from Abstract: AbstractThis paper examines the elements necessary for a practical and successful computerized horse race handicapping and wagering system. Data requirements, handicapping model development, wagering strategy, and feasibility are addressed. A logit-based technique and a corresponding heuristic measure of improvement are described for combining a fundamental handicapping model with the public's implied probability estimates.
The author reports significant positive results in five years of actual implementation of such a system. This result can be interpreted as evidence of inefficiency in pari-mutuel racetrack wagering. This paper aims to emphasize those aspects of computer handicapping which the author has found most important in practical application of such a system.
Keywords:;;;; (search for similar items in EconPapers) JEL-codes: (search for similar items in EconPapers) Date: 2008 References: Citations Downloads: (external link) (application/pdf) (text/html) Ebook Access is available upon purchase. Related works: This item may be available elsewhere in EconPapers: for items with the same title. Export reference: BibTeX RIS (EndNote, ProCite, RefMan) HTML/Text.
Revised 2012 Print or e-Book Save BIG on the e-Book version! From: George Kaywood RE: A Handicapping Breakthrough- Revised in 2012 and now in special e-Book format! Dear Racing Friend: I know what you want! As a handicapper, you want:. An easy-to-use, quick way to spot the real contenders in thoroughbred races. A way that also lets you emphasize your favorite angles. A simple, non-technical way to decide when, how much to bet, and how to bet My Personal Method is the answer.
To properly use this method, you should be at least somewhat familiar with horse race handicapping. Let me tell you-if you're a casual player or a 'Weekend Warrior,' you can easily strengthen how you play with My Personal Method! Now, before I tell you a secret, I've got to tell you that My Personal Method is not a system that generates automatic picks. If you're looking for an old-fashioned system of stiff, no-brainer rules promising unbelievable longshots race after race, stop reading now! My Personal Method is not for you. Do You Know the Secret of Beating the Races?
The secret is: there is no secret! Successful handicapping is a combination of many factors and the experience to know which one to use and which ones to ignore in different races.
One of the biggest problems facing handicappers today is an overload of racing information. My Personal Method shows you how to sort it out. 'Don't I Know Your Name?' I've written numerous articles for American Turf Monthly, the Phillips Racing Newsletter, and other publications. I've been quoted in classic handicapping books by authors like James Quinn and Dick Mitchell. I've been a presenter at Handicapping Expo and I'm the author of Handicapping in Cyberspace: The Horseplayer's Complete Guide to the Internet.
I also own and operate www.handicapping.com, the #1 ranked website on the Internet for handicapping. I wrote the first edition of My Personal Method in 1996, and it quickly became a best-seller! Now, I've updated the Method to reflect the racing realities of today. I've also expanded the work to make it easier to use with examples of races that are easy, typical, and hard ones to handicap! It's as if I'm your personal teacher, standing beside you and walking you through how to use the Method, step by step! You Benefit From One Amazing Discovery After Another Like many great discoveries, the one that led to My Personal Method was somewhat unexpected. While I was doing some racing research, I realized that the order in which you use the basic factors to handicap-speed, class, current form, and so on-is much more important than most players think.
The sequence in which you look at different factors and can the difference between winning and losing a bet! I also re-discovered a great racing truth that is literally hidden in plain sight and how to use it to your advantage. It's a factor that most contemporary handicapping literature recognizes, but fails to use as an integral part of handicapping! Your game will grow much stronger once you re-discover it as well! In revising and upgrading the Method this year, I also discovered something else I wasn't expecting- one of the easiest and most powerful spot plays I've ever seen! My wife asked a 'what if.?'
Researching the answer for her led to this unique spot play. It's easy to understand and use. No Computer Needed! One of the most exciting things about My Personal Method is that you do not need a computer to use it! If you do use a computer to download past performances, speed figures, pace numbers, or other racing information from an online source, you can, of course, incorporate the information into the Method with ease.
If you usually use the Daily Racing Form © or track program Equibase © past performances, you can use either with My Personal Method quickly and easily! Think of the Time and Energy You'll Save The handicapper's biggest enemy is time. Good handicapping takes time. Great handicapping takes more time. You've been there before, haven't you?
If you're under pressure or stress, 'handicapper's fatigue' causes you to make small but deadly mistakes. My Personal Method is thorough yet simple enough to save you time and actually provides a stress-free framework in which you handicap comfortably. No more fatigue to cause those avoidable errors! Extremely Easy to Use Most successful methods today are either too complex or too time-consuming to be used on a regular basis. Not so with My Personal Method.
The Method has only 9 steps- and that includes wagering guidelines and money management! You don't need a calculator or a computer, nor do you need to figure out any difficult ratings for each horse. It Becomes YOUR Personal Method My Personal Method does require some subjective decision-making on your part. That's what handicapping is all about. The Method lets you use the strengths you may have already developed through your preferred style of handicapping to make selections with an extra level of assurance and comfort! Super for Simulcasts If you play primarily at an OTB or simulcast center, you'll love My Personal Method. It enables you to play more than one track by quickly and easily weeding out weaker races and ones that have poor potential for profit.
You'll be playing like a pro by selecting those races which offer good racing and good wagering. Learn How to Make Smarter Decisions My Personal Method combines handicapping and money management to help you make the decision on when to bet a low-odds favorite. Hey, they win one of every three races! But when are they good bets?
Now you can learn how to determine what 'value' really means on your own terms. You'll also learn when to play a legitimate longshot, a high-odds horse that is truly better than his odds warrant. My Personal Method takes into account the racing reality that every player wants and needs to take a reasoned stab at a good score every now and then. Do You Struggle with Money Management? My Personal Method shows you how to determine what 'value' wagering means to you, personally. Once you know this, it's easy to add tote board information into your handicapping process and make intelligent wagers. It's not complicated, and doesn't require a big bankroll or a 'head for numbers.'
Your First Peek Inside I want to give you a little free sample of what's inside the Method. Determining a horse's current form is one of the toughest challenges a horseplayer faces. Are there any easy ways to do this? There sure are, and I explain the fastest and easiest ways to figure it out.
For example, you're given a great clue when a horse is making his second or third start after a layoff. I love to see an even race or two after a layoff, or one in which the horse flashed early speed either by setting the pace to just the first call, or sort of staying near the leader by between 1-3 lengths early without being asked to run particularly fast. These are great tune-up races - these horses often go off and score at generous odds next time they run, in that second or third race after a layoff. When you combine this information with the other highly specific notes in this step of the Method, you'll have a much better understanding of current form than those players who base their bets only on the last race of any given horse. Useful and Profitable My Personal Method was created from a need to make the absolute best use of limited time for handicapping - something that casual players and 'weekend warriors' especially face today. 30 Day Unconditional 100% Money Back Guarantee! You have 30 days to decide if My Personal Method can help you in your approach to the game.
Read it and use it for 30 days and if you don't think it's worth every cent you paid, simply let me know and you'll get an immediate 100% no-hassle refund. NO tricks, NO fine print, NO conditions to this offer, and NO, you don't have to keep betting records! And even if you request a refund, all the free bonuses are yours to keep! How can I make this offer? Because great products should come with great guarantees. The sooner you order My Personal Method, the sooner you'll be playing with more energy, more confidence, and a great money management system. It's one of the best handicapping investments you'll ever make!
Sincerely, George Kaywood. Get Your Copy Today! I want to get your newly-revised book plus the six great free bonuses and start playing like a pro! I also understand that I have an unconditional 30-day satisfaction guarantee and that the bonuses are mine to keep, no matter what! Order anytime from anywhere using our secure server Order Now! E-Book Edition Supported Platforms: Win98/ME/XP/Vista/Win7 Includes:.
Wagering Charts for Exactas, Quinielas, Trifectas, and Superfectas. Exotic Wagering Calculator. Free Dutching Program The Handicapping in Cyberspace e-Book version cannot be printed, and will be locked for use only on the computer you install it on. Easy, secure download, safeguarded to be virus-free. Special packaging self-installs within seconds-no technical know-how required. No waiting for delivery-immediate download available with full instructions emailed to you when your order is placed.
Instant secure download worldwide, 24/7 My Personal Method E-Book Edition NEW LOW PRICE $34.95 You can change the contents of your cart easily anytime before you check out. Printed Edition Comb binding lets you lay the book open flat next to your computer-no spine to break and cause loose pages! Includes:. Wagering Charts for Exactas, Quinielas, Trifectas, and Superfectas. Exotic Wagering Calculator.
Free Dutching Program Free Bonuses included on accompanying CD My Personal Method Print Edition $49.95 plus $4.80 Priority Mail Shipping U.S. Total = $54.75 NOTE: If you wish to order a printed edition from a location other than the U.S. Or Canada, please. Additional shipping charges, tracking and proof of delivery costs increase the total cost significantly.
You can change the contents of your cart easily anytime before you check out. Prefer to Order by Phone? There are many people who prefer to order by telephone, as an added measure of security, avoiding giving out their credit card number on the Internet. If you're one of them, you can place your order by using a toll-free order number, whether you want a printed copy or an e-book edition. Call me personally to order!
This number doesn't ring into some overloaded call center-it rings into MY telephone. You'll talk with me or my wife to place your order and answer any questions you may have. All I ask is that you place your call between 10 a.m. Eastern Time, Mon-Sat, and understand that there may be times when you'll have to leave a message-but we're really good about returning calls asap.
The toll-free number is 888-227-5660. Don't be shocked when a live person answers! Burda magazine free download pdf.
George Kaywood - My Personal Method - Division of Handicapping.com LLC 14409 W 83 Pl Lenexa KS 66215 Phone: 913-310-0075 Email: Copyright © 2010 Handicapping.com All Rights Reserved.
AbstractThis paper examines the elements necessary for a practical and successful computerized horse race handicapping and wagering system. Data requirements, handicapping model development, wagering strategy, and feasibility are addressed. A logit-based technique and a corresponding heuristic measure of improvement are described for combining a fundamental handicapping model with the public's implied probability estimates. The author reports significant positive results in five years of actual implementation of such a system.
This result can be interpreted as evidence of inefficiency in pari-mutuel racetrack wagering. This paper aims to emphasize those aspects of computer handicapping which the author has found most important in practical application of such a system. Suggested Citation. Corrections All material on this site has been provided by the respective publishers and authors. You can help correct errors and omissions.
When requesting a correction, please mention this item's handle: RePEc:wsi:wschap:1920019. See about how to correct material in RePEc. For technical questions regarding this item, or to correct its authors, title, abstract, bibliographic or download information, contact: (Tai Tone Lim). General contact details of provider:.
If you have authored this item and are not yet registered with RePEc, we encourage you to do it. This allows to link your profile to this item. It also allows you to accept potential citations to this item that we are uncertain about. We have no references for this item. You can help adding them by using. If you know of missing items citing this one, you can help us creating those links by adding the relevant references in the same way as above, for each refering item.
If you are a registered author of this item, you may also want to check the 'citations' tab in your profile, as there may be some citations waiting for confirmation. Please note that corrections may take a couple of weeks to filter through the various RePEc services.
Handicapping Software and Horse Racing Data The Betmix horse racing software provides you with a variety of handicapping tools that allow you to win consistently at the racetrack. Using our proprietary slider technology you can select from over 40 handicapping factors and assign specific weights to each factor to create accurate handicapping mixes. Our full featured software allows you to save up to 200 different handicapping profiles for different race tracks, race types, and distances. You can access our comprehensive horse racing database to check your results and build your handicapping systems. Betmix is the on the market, easy to use and proven to find more winners.
Using the powerful artificial intelligence system in the handicapping software, you can have the computer handicap races for you and reveal the most accurate settings for past races. Analyze entire race cards at a glance using the All Races Report. Instantly spot pace and speed advantages and see how horses rank using your saved handicapping systems. Build custom racing reports that focus on specific race types, or search our data base to find every race that meets your selection criteria. Our interactive allow you to see how profitable your handicapping method would have been for a particular day or selection of races. Watch the or read the guide to see how easy it is to handicap with our horse racing software. Try out our handicapping method for free by taking a look at the.
Betmix horse racing data and statistics will provide you with all of the tools and information you need to make winning picks at your favorite tracks. BirdDog The easiest to use and most powerful handicapping software available. Customize what you want to see on your screen. Whether you are a novice or a professional the Betmix BirdDog interface will give you all the information you need to handicap any race. Pick from over a dozen unique widgets that provide data about handicapping factors, computer generated picks, pace analysis, class analysis, Trainer/Owner/Jockey/Sire stats and much more. If you are using a computer to handicap horse races the Betmix software provides all of the horse racing data you need to make the best possible betting decisions. Angler Big Data for horse racing.
Query our database of over 200,000 races to find profitable betting angles. How often does the horse with the best speed last race and best jockey at the meet win?
How often do certain trainer/jockey combos win? How do horses by Tapit do on the dirt vs.
Angler can answer any question you have and give you the percentages and ROI for any date range you choose. Save your Angles and be notified when horses that match your criteria are running today. Command Center Where every handicapper plans their day. Information about all of today’s races one screen. Use the simple interface to find the races you want to play by using filters for track, distance, number of starters, surface and class to find the races that you want to play.
Information about average winning payout, longshot probability and much more at your fingertips. Use the search box to find races with trainers or jockeys you follow or focus on big, well-matched fields that could produce large payouts for exotic wagers. Betmix Labs BetMix Labs is a place to play with some of the new handicapping projects we are developing at Betmix. Think of this as a playground where you can experiment with different ways to analyze a horse race. You will find that these tools offer you a fresh look at how to handicap a race, and they will help give you a deeper understand of the strengths and weaknesses of each horse. Handicapping Journal The Wall Street Journal of horse racing.
Take a look at the Handicapping Journal each day to find out which jockeys, trainers or sires did the best on the previous day. Who were the biggest longshots and where did they run? Which races produced the highest paying exactas, trifectas and superfectas?
Where are favorites winning most and least often and which race types have been the most and least predictive for handicappers. Find out which races today have the most runners or highest purses. See a list of the races that are likely to results in longshot winners or races where the favorites are probably going to win. No matter how you bet or what kinds of races you play, the handicapping journal provides you with very valuable information.
They've got multimillion-dollar bankrolls, lightning-fast networks, and a probability-crunching system that leaves the odds in the dust. Meet the pari-mutuel fund managers who are redefining horse racing.
Crisscrossing telephone wires snake along the carpeting of Rod Dufficy's cluttered home office near Hong Kong's Happy Valley racetrack. Dressed down in baggy black velour sweatpants and a matching gym shirt, Dufficy, 32, sits at a large L-shaped desk, rocking back in his chair and eyeing three computer screens crowded with numbers. He is cramming for a race that begins in 22 minutes, calling up information from an online database and sifting it through a betting-analysis program built into his system. The Australian is one of Hong Kong's elite breed of super-successful professional gamblers, computer-assisted horse bettors who work in teams and net millions at the races each year.
Tonight, however, is not one of Dufficy's big-money sessions; he is down US$300,000 heading into this race. 'I'm going to have a lot of outlay on this next one,' he says.
'Maybe $550,000.' Three slender Hong Kong sisters face Dufficy, waiting for a printer to spit out a list of a couple hundred bets with potentially big payoffs. One sister grabs the sheets and snips them into strips, which she distributes to the other women. They punch the information into their handheld wagering machines, which transmit it to the track via telephone lines, filling the room with the chirping of outgoing data.
Four minutes and three-quarters of a mile later, Dufficy looks up at a large-screen TV and watches thoroughbreds lunging past the finish line. He scrutinizes a fistful of papers, then scans the race results scrolling across his desktop monitor. 'We've got wins - quinellas and a tierce,' he says calmly, referring to wagers that required selecting the first two and three finishers.
He made $330,000 on this single race. 'It'll put me ahead by $30,000 tonight,' he says. By week's end, his earnings will add up to a profit of about $130,000 for essentially two days of work - a typical cycle for Dufficy, who, in fact, wagers and wins less than some other computer-assisted bettors in town.
But there's plenty of dough to go around. As Dufficy and members of the half-dozen or so computer teams in Hong Kong will tell you, this city stands as the land of opportunity for tech-inclined handicappers. The allure centers on Hong Kong's massive handle - the total amount of money wagered on each race - which is the highest in the world.
It allows the teams to lay hundreds of thousands of dollars on a single race without upsetting the odds. But Hong Kong racing has other attractions as well: Run by the not-for-profit Hong Kong Jockey Club, it is scrupulously honest (fixing would hurt computer bettors' calculations), and there is a pool of only 1,200 horses per season (a manageable number for the teams to track performances). Then there are the extravagantly exotic bets and parlays, comprising a rich smorgasbord of financial opportunities that seems custom-made for the computer teams. One, the Triple Trio, requires picking the top three finishers in three races and routinely pays six-figure dividends. 'Racing is becoming more and more like a stock market model,' says one insider.
Horses should be thought of as Dell or Microsoft - their past performances are the equivalent of economic charts. Unlike other sports, in which bookmakers subjectively set the betting odds or point spreads, horse racing is built around a pari-mutuel system.
Payouts are based entirely on the public's opinions, expressed by the horses they bet on. Horses that receive the most bets have the shortest odds and pay the smallest dividends; the least popular horses pay best because fewer people need to divvy up the pool of money. In a pari-mutuel system, the house has no edge and no interest in who wins.
(At the end of a race, the track earns only the fee charged for handling each bet; in Hong Kong it's 19 percent of the wagers, which total about $10 billion each year.) Therefore, someone with the right research capabilities can easily find the public's miscalculations and exploit them for great financial gain. Computer teams pick their winners by culling data from past performances. They use custom-tailored software programs to determine their own odds, search for overlays (situations in which their odds - the calculated, objective odds - are more advantageous than the public's typically subjective odds), and place bets that can deliver big dividends for reduced risk.
Team leaders provide the multimillion-dollar bankrolls, supplemented with investments from the 30 to 40 other members. Their jobs range from accounting to code writing to placing the bets. Annual salaries start at $50,000 for those who enter the wagers by phone and rise to more than $1 million for chief technology officers. The teams are usually headed up by Westerners or Australians; insiders speculate that Chinese gamblers are inclined to emphasize fate and numerology and therefore find computers and horses incompatible. These team leaders walk off with what's left after salaries and operating costs. William Ziemba, alumni professor of financial modeling at the University of British Columbia and a longtime observer of the scene, estimates that a top-notch outfit can pull in as much as $100 million in a good season, netting the boss a cool $50 million or more.
'Computer teams are at a terrific advantage,' explains Richard W. Munchkin, author of the forthcoming Gambling Wizards. 'Imagine if Fidelity were the only professional investing company, and all the other investors were amateurs who chose stocks at random, on the weekends, for entertainment. Fidelity would be making a lot of money at the expense of those less serious investors.' While computer-generated horse picking is not particularly new, it has reached an apex of sophistication in Hong Kong and is spreading beyond China. Teams have recently made inroads in the United States and Japan.
You can easily spot tech bettors at the track in Tokyo because they're the ones wheeling suitcases filled with yen. In the US, seven-figure windfalls are unlikely because of small racetrack handles, but pick sixes (choosing the winning horse in six races) paying over $100,000 are possible. In Hong Kong, computer-assisted teams are not illegal, but the Jockey Club frowns on the practice, and some bettors claim the HKJC has shut down their accounts after it discovered they were connected to teams. 'I'm running out of trustworthy people to hold accounts for me,' half-gripes, half-brags one Australian bettor. While complaining that his wife's account was canceled, he is well aware of the professional gambler's credo: If they're not throwing you out, you're doing something wrong. Competition among Hong Kong's computer teams is fierce. Technological secrets are closely guarded, nobody's keen to publicize their betting strategies, and the cagiest players aim to hide their wagers from other teams - all of which monitor the flow of racing money via an independent online service called Telequote, based in Hong Kong.
Nobody's more skilled at masking bets than Bill Benter, regarded by many of his peers as the most successful sports bettor in the world: 'Normally, you'd see the odds go from 141-1 to 116-1 and know it's got to be a big professional bet,' says Dufficy. 'But Bill has his betting model set to disguise his action with little $5,000 dribbles.
He ultimately puts the right amount on a horse, but he does it over a sequence of time. He leaves no footprints, and that drives other bettors crazy.' The prevailing paranoia is summed up by a rebuffing email from another big player, who refused an on-the-record interview, chiding: 'To highlight what I do only INVITES competition, so a high tech magazine is the least desirable place to have an article about me appear. Plus, any publicity is also very bad in terms of impact on the Jockey Club. They do not like computer teams, so advertising how much we make will only hurt us.' Nonetheless, several team leaders agreed to talk about their operations, though not for attribution. Working from mathematical models that are calculated to deliver a 24 percent return on investments, Hong Kong's most sophisticated computer-assisted bettors operate with long-term certainty of what their profits should be.
'Racing is becoming more and more like a stock market model,' says Ziemba, who specializes in statistical analysis and edited The Efficiency of Racetrack Betting Markets, a collection of scholarly papers on the mathematics of horse wagering that includes a chapter by Benter outlining the system used in Hong Kong. Horses should be thought of as Microsoft or Dell, Ziemba says, and their past performances are the equivalent of economic charts that provide fodder for the Street's quantitative analysts. 'Racing is a financial market catching up with the rest of the world. One big difference, though, between the stock market and a horse race is that you can choose when you want to take your profits from a stock. With horses you must do it at the end of each race. So there is a lot more action.' Benter, for example, has employees whose sole job it is to review race tapes after every meet.
They judge each horse on 130 characteristics - attributes like speed during the first third of the race, whether it got bumped coming out of a turn, the quality of its recovery from the bump, and, of course, how it finished - and assign numerical grades. This information goes into the database, where it can be cross-referenced and called up to help predict the outcome of any impending race that particular horse runs in. The computer essentially simulates the race before it happens, based on what has transpired in the past and any anticipated conditions in the future. The software then determines each horse's likelihood of winning a race.
When a horse's computer-generated odds are better than the public's odds, the team slams in its wagers. 'You create a model that can analyze each type of bet, judge the conditions in terms of money in the pool and the associated odds, and tell you when it will be most favorable to bet,' explains Ziemba. 'You do not necessarily want to bet a ton every time - you only do it when you can find advantages.' One top bettor explains it like this: 'Our computer program churns through the history of the horses and adjusts all the probability in a very sophisticated way.
Having established the probability of the horses, we feed that into our betting program, which looks at all the odds for the various outcomes. It looks at your true chances of winning with the latest payoff odds and calculates what the best potential bets are, based on the chances of winning and the odds. Then it runs through all the probabilities. 'The mathematical aspect involves following a basic formulation that all successful gamblers use - whether they know it or not,' the bettor says.
'It's having what mathematicians call a positive expectation on the bet. You multiply the probability of winning times the payoff odds of one bet. Let's say the horse is 20-1. If it has a.05 probability of winning, you multiply that by 20-1.
You get 1.0 - or 1-1 - and that is a fair payoff bet. The teams excel at complex bets. The biggest Triple Trio ever, paying $18 million, was snagged by a pair of computer-assisted players who covered 900,000 possibilities with wagers totaling $1.2 million. 'But if that same horse is paying 25-1, then it has a positive expectation. Now it is 1.25 or 1.25-1. It gives you a 25 percent edge. Given that you know the true probability of winning, the amount to bet is a closed-form problem based on how much you can lay down without hurting your odds.'
Designing the software to do all this is a delicate operation with seemingly endless pitfalls that can disastrously skew the results. 'You have to understand,' says Ziemba, 'that building this system, maintaining it every week, and updating the model once a year is a lot of work.' And doing the work does not necessarily guarantee success.
Benter went broke at least once before his system was efficient enough to turn a steady profit. Free download mp3 lagu celine dion to love you more. 'Every year, more and more people come here and leave with their tail between their legs,' says Dufficy.
Whoever writes the team's software needs to decide early on which aspects of a horse's performance to take most seriously. For instance, if a debuting horse's odds of winning are 50-1 and it wins its first race, the software will note that - and might be inclined to view untried horses with long odds as good bets. So the system must be tweaked to give little weight to those outcomes.
Other, more ambiguous factors - turf firmness, recent time trials, second-place finishes, and the jockeys' racing styles, to name a few - must also be taken into account. 'Memory is another thing,' suggests Kelly Busche, an economist who has taught at Hong Kong University and consulted for one of the major teams in town. 'How quickly do you discount information? And to what degree?
What happened two seasons ago should carry less weight than what happened last season. You need a model and a database that are both agile and robust enough to handle a variety of ever-changing situations.'
To build a good horse racing model, teams rely on workers with the skills of hedge fund technicians. Rumor has it that one of the teams has wooed programmers from Fortune 500 companies. 'You need a hardcore nerd who is good with numbers and has a mathematical and engineering background,' says one team leader. 'What we do with computers here is similar to what you see with Deep Blue.
It's about attacking problems by fussing around and fine-tuning rather than using intuitive knowledge.' Bettors believe the Jockey Club created big, complex bets like the Triple Trio as a hedge against the computer teams' skill-based advantages. The idea was that such wagers would be impossible to handicap, thus enhancing the luck factor and leveling the field. But things have not worked out that way. The biggest Triple Trio ever, paying a dividend of $18 million, was snagged by a pair of computer-assisted players who covered 900,000 possibilities with bets totaling $1.2 million. The top teams routinely make their fortunes through complicated parlays, quinellas, and exactas.
Never mind that most teams risk huge sums for their reward and shell out an estimated $95 million in commissions. The HKJC remains - at least publicly - unimpressed. 'We are worried that if you have the computer people, then your average customer sees himself as having no chance,' says Winfried Engelbrecht-Bresges, the HKJC's executive director of racing. 'But they're the bettors who bring us 95 percent of our revenue.'
The story of computer-assisted betting in Hong Kong begins with Bill Benter, the US-educated, impeccably dressed technician who developed the first successful program put to use at Happy Valley. The importance of his pioneering work is confirmed by rivals and experts alike.
Benter got his start in the mid-1970s, when he discovered Beat the Dealer, a bible for blackjack card counters. He memorized the best-selling book's strategies and hit the casino circuit, where he met his future partner Alan Woods, a former actuary turned counter. It was in Las Vegas that Benter stumbled upon a slender handicapping guide - and turned from casinos to horse racing. Equipped with a $150,000 bankroll provided mostly by Woods, the two card counters planned to apply the theories of winning at blackjack to winning at the races. Beat the Dealer, after all, had been written with the aid of a computer that analyzed every possible situation at a blackjack table and assigned numerical values based on which cards remained in the deck.
The idea, when you follow that best-selling guide, is to rigorously stick to its formula and bet high even when you have only a tiny advantage. In the long run, despite frequent fluctuations and potentially long periods of losing, you will win a prescribed percentage of money.
By the time Benter refined his program to the point where it worked consistently, he and Woods had bitterly fallen out over money disputes. But in the end, each wound up with an odds- and probability-crunching machine - both built by Benter. Woods is still on the scene, but his working style is described as being completely different from Benter's.
He uses off-the-rack Pentium computers, still runs DOS, and employs an out-of-print program called Revelation for his database. At its core, it remains the original system created by his former partner, customized so that Woods can override it with his personal input. Benter now works with Sun Microsystems processors and uses the far more stable Unix operating system. His setup is said to be much more finely tuned than Woods', allowing him to reach conclusions with limited human interface, thus permitting fewer opportunities for subjective opinions to foul up the beautiful mathematics.
When Benter's winners cross the finish line, you don't hear so much as a whoop from his crew. As any fan can tell you, the real miracle of this technology is that winning fails to come as much of a surprise.
Computer Based Horse Race Handicapping And Wagering Systems Pdf
The Hong Kong model seems to be catching on. Consider that as the horses bolted from the starting gate at Gulfstream Park in Hallandale Beach, Florida, one day in February last year, the odds for the winning horse suddenly went from 10-1 to 8-1.
A gambler reported the shift to Gulfstream's vice president of finance, Bob Zambreny Jr., who did a bit of investigating. He discovered that in a three-second span, 167 exacta wagers were placed from an outfit in Fargo, North Dakota, called Racing Services - a discreet betting parlor that attracts sky-high wagers with low commissions and liberal rules. Further snooping uncovered a computer team operating in the United States using handicapping software similar to the systems used by Hong Kong teams. Zambreny and Racing Services decline to identify the team leader. But whoever it was had a special interface that allowed him to batch his bets - to place dozens of wagers per second - into the Racing Services system.
This allowed the team to lay down a skein of complex exacta wagers after nearly all wagers were in, the odds were practically set, and it was relatively clear as to how much could be staked before upsetting the odds beyond a tolerable degree. The bets, automatically placed by the computer, ultimately paid out $246,020 on a total bet of $25,569. Even more impressive, over a 50-day period, the team had reportedly netted $3.3 million in profits on $12.9 million in bets. Gulfstream quickly barred the team from using a computer to place bets, asserting that all bettors must have an even chance.
But Susan Bala, president of Racing Services, plays down the unique access granted to the team and says she would let any customer place his wagers via computer from her shop. 'We haven't had Joe Blow come in off the street and ask us to let him use his computer in here.
But if he did, we would talk to him. We're a service company.' Computerized betting is giving horse racing a much-needed dose of pizzazz, Bala argues.
She hopes that computer-assisted betting will attract the same people to racing who once devoted afternoons to daytrading. 'Technology is driving horse racing to new places,' she says. Other racing professionals are beginning to come around. After the Gulfstream incident, US racing executives discussed the possibility of introducing computerized betting. 'I can see a future where patrons would be able to plug their laptops into docking stations,' acknowledges Zambreny. 'They would deliver their bets through computers and the batching of bets would be possible.'
Barry Schwartz, chair of the New York Racing Association, welcomes high tech action: 'Computers are simply another tool for handicapping. There's no guarantee of winning just because you're using one. These bettors are willing to risk money just like everyone else.' No guarantees, but the evidence from Hong Kong suggests it's the closest thing to a sure bet. There, the models have been taken as far as they can go, and it will be up to a new generation of Benters to tweak them for use in other locales.
As handicapping systems seep into the mainstream, the innovators anticipate a future involving artificial intelligence - a Kubrickian computer that blends the human sensitivity of the best old-fashioned gamblers with the brute force of a supercomputer. If that day ever comes, traditional horse bettors may really have something to worry about.
Comments are closed.
|
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |